Skip links

Choosing the Right Contractor: Unconventional Questions to Ask Before You Hire

Hiring the right contractor can make or break your project. Conventional wisdom tells us to check experience, licensing, and insurance. But is that enough? Often, these typical criteria fall short. In this post, we’ll explore unconventional questions for hiring contractors to help you make the best decision. Whether you’re renovating your home or embarking on a commercial project, these insights will guide you.

Choosing the Right Contractor Unconventional Questions to Ask Before You Hire-2

The Dominant Narrative

When choosing a contractor, the standard advice is to ask about experience, check licenses, and read reviews. While these are important, they don’t always guarantee success. For instance, many homeowners face issues even after hiring well-recommended contractors. According to a study by Consumer Reports, 27% of homeowners experienced problems with contractors despite positive reviews.

Questioning Experience Over Innovation

Experience is often seen as the ultimate indicator of a contractor’s capability. But what about innovation? Some less experienced contractors may offer innovative solutions that outperform seasoned professionals.

Consider the example of a young contractor who designed a cost-effective, eco-friendly home renovation that won industry awards. Sometimes, innovative contractor selection criteria can lead to exceptional results.

Beyond Licensing and Insurance

Licensing and insurance are non-negotiable, but they aren’t foolproof. There are numerous cases where licensed and insured contractors delivered subpar work.

 “How do you handle unexpected challenges or errors on the job?”

This question reveals how a contractor deals with problems, which is crucial. A report by Remodeling Magazine highlighted that 15% of projects face significant delays or issues due to unforeseen challenges.

Glowing references and reviews can be misleading. There are instances where the actual performance didn’t match the hype.

References and Reviews: A Double-Edged Sword

Glowing references and reviews can be misleading. There are instances where the actual performance didn’t match the hype.

“Can you show me a project that didn’t go as planned and explain how you managed it?”

By asking this, you can gauge the contractor’s problem-solving skills and honesty. A survey by HomeAdvisor found that 25% of homeowners felt misled by contractor reviews.

The Pitfall of Specialization

Specialized contractors aren’t always the best choice. Sometimes, generalists with a broader skill set can handle diverse aspects of a project better.

“How do you ensure a holistic approach to the project?”

Consider a case where a specialized contractor focused only on their niche, ignoring crucial elements outside their expertise, leading to project delays and extra costs.

Price Isn’t Everything

Choosing the cheapest or the most expensive option can backfire. Hidden costs and unforeseen complications can arise.

 “What are the potential hidden costs or financial risks associated with this project?”

A report from the National Association of Home Builders shows that 30% of construction projects exceed their initial budget due to hidden costs.

Communication Skills and Customer Service

Technical skills are crucial, but so are communication skills. Poor communication can lead to misunderstandings and project failures.

“How do you keep your clients informed throughout the project?”

A survey by the Better Business Bureau found that clear communication was a top priority for 40% of clients when hiring a contractor.

Trust Your Gut

Trusting your instincts is vital. Sometimes, your gut feeling can be more accurate than a portfolio or references.

“What measures do you take to build trust with your clients?”

Personal intuition often plays a significant role in the success of a contractor-client relationship.


Choosing the right contractor involves more than just ticking boxes. By asking unconventional questions, you can uncover deeper insights and make a well-informed decision. Don’t just follow the standard checklist; think critically and trust your judgment. Remember, the right contractor should not only have the skills but also the right attitude and approach.

Choosing the Right Contractor Unconventional Questions to Ask Before You Hire-3

Call to Action

Ready to start your next project? Download our checklist of unconventional questions to ask contractors. For more tips, subscribe to our newsletter or contact us today!

Would you like to discuss with us how we could update your home?

Leave a comment

This website uses cookies to improve your web experience.